How This Woman Turned Mushroom Foraging Into a Career

Diane Summers-Yelton, otherwise known as The Mushroom LADY, turned a hobby into a food lover’s dream career.

When her two kids were little, Diane Summers-Yelton would frequently spend time with them outside, far away from the TV, exploring the natural world.

Then living in New England, the young mother would carry one child in a backpack and lead the other by the hand and head off on a nearby park trail. “I would say to my son, ‘Let’s stop and roll this log over and see what’s under there. Oh, some bugs and snakes and other lifeforms.’ Then we’d turn the log back over gently to keep their habitat safe.” When they’d run into a spot where a mushroom was growing, her son would inevitably say, curiously, “What is this?” She’d pull him away with the warning, “That’s poison!” And they’d keep moving. Along with the lessons she taught her children, Summers-Yelton soaked up the time connecting with the outdoors. “I’m happiest when I’m in the woods, at peace.”

Flash forward 15 years or so. Summers-Yelton’s kids are grown, she’s given up her corporate career and she and her husband are settled in the Milwaukee area. Her love of nature and “huge thirst for knowing what I don’t know” has turned a hobby into something much bigger. In the course of those double-digit years of MKE living, she’s become an expert in the world of edible fungi, turning what for some might be a personal diversion into a full-fledged business – called The Mushroom LADY LLC (all caps in honor of the few “rock star” women who forage avidly in the area). She has delivered hen of the woods, morels, pheasant backs, chanterelles and many more species into the hands of over 30 restaurant chefs from Milwaukee west to Lake Country and north to Sheboygan.

Photo by Getty Images

Trusting a forager takes time. There are no diplomas she can show a chef to prove she’s legit. But she doesn’t take no for an answer, and she built her clientele through full immersion in the craft – from near-incessant study (“I read one book in particular for 10 years. It’s like a bible”) and spending as much time in the woods as some people do in an office. The occupational hazards are numerous. She has been stared down by a coyote, nearly attacked by a bobcat, and has gotten lost more times than she can count. And things are nearly as treacherous on the business side. Summers-Yelton calls mushroom foraging a “ruthless” business, and prefers not to name her chef customers for fear that competitors will try to steal her clients.

Home cooks can buy from her directly through her Facebook page, The Mushroom Lady LLC, or at the Whitefish Bay Farmers Market in summer. And during truffle seasons, she operates a steady import business, bringing in the prized black and white truffles from France and Italy.

In spring – in three layers of clothing, carrying her lucky backpack (packed with, among many useful things, two compasses, a silver marathoner’s thermal blanket, emergency whistle, lighter and magnifying glass) and often accompanied by her hound dog Marshall – she ventures to places that aren’t overrun with professional and amateur foragers, seeking out certain indicator plants to find the beloved morels. She admits to not typically finding many of them. But she always has plenty of mesh mushroom bags and large trash bags in tow in case she finds a “mother lode” of any species.Early spring also finds her in pursuit of the pheasant back mushroom (or dryad’s saddle). From April to November, “each month reveals a few different wild edible mushrooms,” she says. This month, we’ll begin to see Mother Nature preparing to reveal her bounty. Of the Mother, Summers-Yelton says, “She never disappoints. She delivers, and I take – respectfully.” 


Breaded Morel Mushrooms with Sage, Thyme and Butter

The delicate, prized morel mushroom has a very short window of availability, so make the most of it. Summers-Yelton shared this favorite way of preparing them from thekitchn.com:

1/2 pound of morel mushrooms | 3 eggs | About 2 cups of panko breadcrumbs | 2 teaspoons of salt (plus more for soaking the morels) | 2 teaspoons of pepper | Several sprigs of fresh thyme, de-stemmed | 1 tablespoon of dried sage | 1 stick of butter |2 tablespoons of olive oil

→ Begin by soaking the morels for a few hours in cold, salty water. This will kill any critters that might be living in the hollows of the mushrooms. Rinse them well, and cut them in half lengthwise (if you have really big mushrooms, cut them into quarters). 

→ Put the breadcrumbs in a shallow dish, and combine with salt, pepper, sage and thyme. Crack the eggs into a bowl, and lightly beat them.

→ Next, add the butter and olive oil to a large skillet, and set over medium to medium-high heat. Once the butter is melted and hot, begin dipping the mushrooms – first in egg, then in the breadcrumbs. Fry the mushrooms in the butter until they’re nice and golden, being careful to do them in batches and not crowd the pan. Eat them while they’re hot, and, if you like, dip them in some warm, garlicky tomato sauce.

Photo by Jarvis Lawson

You like truffles? The Mushroom Lady is stocked with various delicacies, including imported black truffle oil, handmade black truffle butter, handmade pink black truffle salt, and black truffle honey imported from France. To buy them, contact her via her Facebook page.


 

This story is part of Milwaukee Magazine‘s March issue. 

Find it on newsstands or buy a copy at milwaukeemag.com/shop

Be the first to get every new issue. Subscribe.

Comments

comments

Ann Christenson has covered dining for Milwaukee Magazine since 1997. She was raised on a diet of casseroles that started with a pound of ground beef and a can of Campbell's soup. Feel free to share any casserole recipes with her.