Behind Elsa’s on the Park’s Great Service | Milwaukee Magazine
Elsa's on the Park manager John Jordan wear a white shirt and black tie and smiles while seated at a table.

Meet the Man Behind Elsa’s On the Park’s Exceptional Service

Manager John Jordan shares why he goes all out to make customers feel special.

In the world of restaurant service, there are woefully few John Jordans. The manager of Elsa’s on the Park is known for his above-and-beyond approach to service. We’re talking the red-carpet treatment, setting the tone for the front-of-house staff at the Downtown establishment known for expertly crafted cocktails and upscale bar food. Jordan says his philosophy is a culmination of years of enhancing the customer experience (at American TV, Grand Appliance and others) and knowing it’s about, simply, making people feel special. He shared his insights with MilMag:

You don’t have a food and beverage industry background. What drew you to Elsa’s?

In my previous jobs, I was the how-do-I-make-this-right-for-the-client person. It was actually a friend [who] said, “Hey, you know you’ve been going down there for over 30 years ordering those cocktails two to three times a week, you might as well take the job.” I said, “What job?” He said, “Manager.” I went down to interview, and they asked me, “What do you know about hospitality?” I said, “I don’t know a damn thing. The truth is I am customer service. I have dealt with customer service so much in my life – what I want and what I think is meaningful to people. I think I can bring that to your company. And I think I can take us to the next level with our staffing and educate our youth on what hospitality is.”


Tell us who you’d pick to be a Betty this year!

 

What makes good service?

I want to be spoiled when I go out. If I’m spending that money, I’m paying you to give me service. So that’s what we do. Always make sure [patrons] have everything they need, allow them to sit back, relax and enjoy the festivities of what we serve. When [owner] Karl [Kopp] sees me, [sometimes] he’s like, “John, you’re doing a lot. You know you don’t need to do that.” But I want [the front-of-house staff] to see.

What do you think makes Elsa’s special?

My first time there, I had just turned 21. Karl met me at the door. “Welcome to Elsa’s on the Park.” He walked me to my seat, sat me down – talk about someone who sets an example for others to follow. He is the machine; he is the essence of what you call perfection. Meeting him, I felt welcome. And then, the staff – you don’t look for a therapist or psychologist or anything, but the bartenders are always interesting, and they engage with you.

How do you educate your younger front-of-house staff?

I want them to understand there’s nothing that I will ask them to do [that] I won’t do. If they see me doing it, this should be contagious. If they see a fork dropping, I want [them] to be able to catch it before it hits the floor. That level of attention.


This story is part of Milwaukee Magazine’s October issue.

Find it on newsstands or buy a copy at milwaukeemag.com/shop.

Be the first to get every new issue. Subscribe.

Ann Christenson has covered dining for Milwaukee Magazine since 1997. She was raised on a diet of casseroles that started with a pound of ground beef and a can of Campbell's soup. Feel free to share any casserole recipes with her.