This Gas Station Owner Made Caring His Business

This Gas Station Owner Made Caring His Business

Faisal Bhimani’s acts of kindness have given his South Side gas stations a devoted following

Between painful fuel prices, overpriced junk food and losing lottery tickets, it can feel like gas stations just take and take. But Faisal Bhimani’s two South Side gas stations, across Howard Avenue from one another at Clement Avenue, have developed a different reputation: for giving and a sense of community. 

Bhimani’s BP station looks typical. There are three aisles of snack food, a wall of coolers, coffee and frozen drink machines bathed in fluorescent light. What stands out are the less visible acts of generosity: free bottles of water on scorching hot days, space outside for lemonade stands and bake sale fundraisers for local charities like Project Concern and the Bay View Pantry. A donation jar on the counter is tallied at the end of every week and matched by Bhimani to buy $10 worth of free gas for seniors 65 and older on a limited budget. The station even hosted a customer appreciation day with free food. 

To Bhimani, being generous to the neighborhood is about paying back the customers who have been kind to him. “You get to know their family, their needs and necessities,” Bhimani said. “You feel a bond. When they ask for help, you help them out because they’ve helped you.” Bhimani cites a time when construction shut down Howard Avenue. Instead of ditching him, “customers were circling around to find a way into the station,” Bhimani said. “It pushed me to do more for the community.” 


Gift An Issue For $12 Today!

 

Bhimani, who purchased his stations from his father in 2007, typically wakes at 3 a.m. to work a shift at the BP from 4-7 or 8, then does paperwork in a small office in the back before heading across the street to check in at the Citgo. The door chimes announce a steady stream of customers whom Bhimani cheerfully greets, many by name. He says his favorite part of the job is this time he gets to spend joking and chatting with his regulars. 

“He goes above and beyond, always willing to give” says Sheron Borchardt, who has been a regular for over 15 years, and stops in frequently for cigarettes and lottery tickets. “If someone is having a hard day, he makes them laugh.”

Bhimani’s parents migrated here from Pakistan in 1989. His father and two uncles bought a convenience store on 34th and Lincoln, and by 2010, the family owned about 17 stations. Bhimani began working for them, starting as a cooler stocker when he graduated from high school in 2000. The gas station business is a grind, Bhimani added, and the rest of his family has transitioned to laundromats and restaurants. 

His parents moved to Dallas last year, and Bhimani strongly considered following. Customers sometimes complain to him about the price of gas, and the long hours make him wish for more time with his wife and sons, 6 and 10, and daughter, 14. But as Bhimani was considering selling, a letter from a loyal customer telling him how much he was appreciated gave him pause. 

“It really inspired me. I talked to my wife and we were like, you know what, let’s stick around and see what happens,” said Bhimani. He’ll give it a few more years, but is still considering opening a restaurant here or moving his family to join his parents in Texas. 

“No!” Borchardt shouts when she hears that. “Oh my God, if he leaves, I will follow him wherever he goes,” she laughs.

“He’s not going to leave,” adds Joann Burger, a loyal customer for 19 years, with a mock threat: “The customers aren’t going to let him.”


This story is part of Milwaukee Magazine’s November 2026 issue.

Find it on newsstands or buy a copy at milwaukeemag.com/shop.

Be the first to get every new issue. Subscribe. 

Tea Krulos is a contributing writer to Milwaukee Magazine, an author and event organizer.