In our most pungent Office Taste Test ever, our staff took on the condiment that defines everything from a hot dog to a Cuban sandwich.
In this month of sloshy Oktoberfest beer steins, dirndls and casing-wrapped meat, we mustn’t forget about mustard – a gewürz, as pretzel-chewing Germans call a seasoning or condiment. We tasked our editorial staff with finding the unsurpassed in an informal judging of six Wisconsin-made mustards. The tangy, pungent and, in some cases, sweet notes were best sampled with the Bavarian accompaniment of soft, chewy pretzels, procured from the terrific Riverwest-based Milwaukee Pretzel Company.
Silver Spring Spicy Brown Deli-style Mustard
Not too assertive or dominant in heat, pungency or tanginess. The Eau Claire-hailing mustard has a “well-balanced,” horseradishy finish that “would make it great with ham,” says a taster.
Sprecher Spicy Brown Beer Mustard
A hit with staffers who appreciated the hot-sweet duality, a keen combo of honey, mustard seed, white wine, a hint of paprika and, of course, Sprecher beer.
Patz Honey Mustard
Made by a company (in Pound, Wis.) known for honey and maple syrup, this recruit won over one fan with its “bright, vinegary” flavor, which seems an ideal partner for a chicken nugget.