Jake Horstmeier was raised on Dr. Seuss’ How the Grinch Stole Christmas! – more specifically, the 1966 cartoon animated by Chuck Jones. That mischievous Grinchy grin and unfurling tuft of hair? “It freaked me out, but also totally drew me in,” he says. From this formative holiday tradition to reciting the Boris Karloff narration from memory to his own son at bedtime, he’s been training to don the furry green suit his whole life.
This month, the actor and Random Lake native will finally take the stage as Dr. Seuss’ infamous grouch in First Stage’s musical production. Although Karloff’s baritone growl is etched in his brain, Horstmeier aims to steal Christmas – and hearts – with his own interpretation.
First Stage’s rendition follows the 2006 Broadway musical adaptation, narrated in retrospect by the Grinch’s trusty dog, Max. These stage-show qualities, combined with the intimate space of the Marcus Center’s Todd Wehr Theater, have inspired a vaudevillian approach to the production.
Horstmeier plans to deviously exploit that intimacy and play to the crowd, changing things up a smidge show by show. “In the Todd Wehr, the actors are in your laps,” he said. “If somebody’s on their phone, I’m probably going to take it away. I mean, it’s the Grinch – what would he do? He’s an intense guy.”
As Horstmeier sees it, the musical numbers feed directly into the Grinch’s primary motivations of seeking attention and connection. Zealous singing, brash dancing, cantankerous mingling: “It’s the perfect vehicle to kick the Grinch’s larger-than-life personality into overdrive.” But whether Horstmeier’s Grinch will be cartoonishly nasty, subtle and sly, or a lovable grump? That depends on the scene. “In the script itself, the Grinch is described as Jack Nicholson on a bender,” Horstmeier said. “As an actor, that gives me a lot of information.”
Peeling back the Grinch’s deep-down sense of compassion has also informed Horstmeier’s take. “For a non-human creature, the Grinch is incredibly human,” he said. “We’re surrounded by examples of flawed, sometimes broken people who choose to take the selfish path at the expense of others – and we’re left wondering why. Cindy Lou even asks the Grinch point blank: ‘Santy Claus, why?’ … I’m digging into my own answers to Cindy Lou’s question.” To Horstmeier, the Grinch remains an ever-relevant American story. “This creature spends the whole time [angry] because he’s not a part of the joy,” he remarked. “All it takes is somebody saying, ‘Well, why don’t you come be a part of it?’ You can’t actually steal the spirit of the season, because it’s really about connectedness and togetherness. That’s a pretty incredible message for right now.”
See: First Stage’s How the Grinch Stole Christmas! The Musical from Nov. 21-Dec. 27.


