La Sirena Brings High Quality Dining to Door County

La Sirena Brings High Quality Dining to Door County

Armed with heirloom ingredients and the desire for a more balanced life, a former California couple brings modern Mexican fine dining to Door County.

It sounds like a screenplay – the owners of an acclaimed restaurant in California shut down their culinary brainchild while at the top of their game and uproot for a slower-paced life in the Midwest. They open a restaurant inside a charming little white cottage in an area replete with charming little white cottages. Their first year in business is a wild success.   

But this is not a work of fiction. It’s the story of Door County’s La Sirena, which I made a goal to visit last summer. (It took patience, but I finally got a reservation for a Thursday in late August.)  

Like the owners’ previous restaurant, Taco María in Costa Mesa, La Sirena works with specific growers to craft its modern Mexican American menu, whose unifier is heirloom corn sourced from small farms in rural Mexico. Chef and co-owner Carlos Salgado is an heirloom corn evangelist. When you taste his blue corn tortillas, you’ll get it. They have a distinct, masa-y, nutty flavor that comes from landrace corn, which has high genetic diversity. Commercially made corn tortillas don’t have that heritage or cultural history because the majority of the American-grown crop is genetically modified.  


Gift An Issue For $1 Today!

 

Pollo con Raja (chicken, chihuahua peppers, onion cream and roasted grapes) at La Sirena restaurant in the town of Ephraim, Door County, WI. Photo by Kevin J. Miyazaki

Heirloom corn is critically important to the DNA of La Sirena (Spanish for The Mermaid or The Siren), and both of the courses on the prix-fixe menu ($60) the night I visited featured it. (The format ranges from two to four courses, depending on what’s in season.)

Our meal was gluten-free, and one of the first questions our server asked was about food allergies. Did we have any? Yes, actually, a tomato allergy for one in my party. Although this fruit is almost as essential to Mexican cuisine as corn, the kitchen pivoted to make not simply adequate substitutions but mods that didn’t leave my friend wondering what he was missing.  

Salgado seems accustomed to shifts. He grew up in a restaurant family in Orange County. After briefly pursuing a tech career, he switched to cooking and met his wife, Wisconsin native Emilie Coulson Salgado, when he was working as a pastry chef in San Francisco. In 2013, they opened Taco María, where Salgado became known for his contributions to a style gaining momentum in SoCal called Alta California cuisine. It deviates from commercialized, chips-and-salsa-slinging Mexican American cuisine to a complex, soulful merging of ancestral Mexican traditions and foods with the formal training garnered in California restaurant kitchens. A marriage of old culinary customs and new.  

Despite oodles of recognition (James Beard Award noms, a Michelin star four straight years), Taco María closed after 10 years, the owners saying they’d outgrown the space and wouldn’t be renewing the lease. That led to the Salgados’ relocation to Emilie’s native Door County and the creation of La Sirena. It, too, is getting national recognition – in September, The New York Times named La Sirena one of its 50 Best Restaurants in America for 2026. 

Pescadilla, top (smoked whitefish taco, marinated cucumber, chile morita with peanut) and Tostada de Jitomate, bottom (heirloom tomato, lima bean aioli, pistachio salsa macha, cilantro and mint) at La Sirena restaurant in the town of Ephraim, Door County, WI. Photo by Kevin J. Miyazaki

Occupying a small footprint (less than 30 seats), it opened as summer 2025 was winding down, which was strategic on the Salgados’ part. Their plan was to offer a limited menu over the quiet fall and winter seasons, get to know the locals and figure out what La Sirena would be – which is ultimately a modern amalgam of Mexican American cuisine and Wisconsin influences.  

The simplicity of La Sirena’s physical space seemed fitting for a chef who values approachability over excess. The cottage is bright white, spartan and completely elegant in its unpretentiousness. From my seat at the L-shaped bar, I’d occasionally catch glimpses of the back-of-the-house through a half-round window to the kitchen. The dining room felt controlled but relaxed. 

The two-course menu was the evening’s program, with just one decision: pintata (guinea hen) or pescado (fish) for the main course. My partner and I didn’t need to flip a coin because both sounded great. Every component of the tostada de jitomate first course – a tortilla layered with lima bean aioli, pistachio salsa macha, juicy heirloom tomato, flowering cilantro and fresh mint – brought its own, fresh, bright dimension, but there was simply nothing like the base of it. The blue corn tostada Salgado makes using nixtamalized corn (boiled and soaked in an alkaline solution, then milled and used to make masa) is the glue that holds everything together. Eating it is having the realization that this is what a tostada is supposed to taste like – not the pedestrian, almost anemic things served in typical Mexican restaurants but this perfectly crisp, nutty, vibrantly earthy tortilla. I wanted – needed – seconds, and more.  

La Sirena restaurant in Ephraim, Door County, WI. Photo by Kevin J. Miyazaki

The entrées were served family style, with the vessels of oregano rice, saucy heirloom beans and a chunky guacamole, plus a warmer of fresh blue corn tortillas, scattered across the wooden bartop. Each of the mains was a dream. The pescado was a fleshy, translucent and perfectly cooked salmon filet (Wisconsin-raised) in a fruity tomatillo sauce studded with kernels of sweet corn. But the spatchcocked guinea hen refused to be outdone – it presented as an ample breast and thigh of succulent meat in a nutty permission mole. The tacos we made were next level. It wasn’t one single thing but everything together – the smoky beans, that fluffy, light-as-air rice, and above all, the tortillas, with their deep, earthy flavor. The decision to add on dessert ($15) was made due to four letters: F-L-A-N. This Latin custard is one of my favorite desserts ever, flecked with vanilla bean seeds and topped with Door County-approved tart-sweet sangria cherries. 

Initially, the couple were unsure how the locals would react to a fine dining Mexican restaurant. But Salgado says he’s “grateful and pleasantly surprised at how open-hearted and open-minded our dining community has been so far. We’re not out here trying to build a little Noma at the end of the Door County Peninsula. We’re just trying to do our best work with the products and resources that we have, and make it nice.”


La Sirena 

9996 Pioneer Lane, Ephraim, 920-854-3232 

Hours: Wed-Sat 5-9 p.m.

Prices: Multi-course prix-fixe menus $60-$80. Desserts $8-$16 

Reservations: Necessary.

service: Gracious, experienced, polished, genuine


This story is part of Milwaukee Magazine’s November 2026 issue.

Find it on newsstands or buy a copy at milwaukeemag.com/shop.

Be the first to get every new issue. Subscribe. 

Ann Christenson has covered dining for Milwaukee Magazine since 1997. She was raised on a diet of casseroles that started with a pound of ground beef and a can of Campbell's soup. Feel free to share any casserole recipes with her.