“A Gift of The Magi” Makes Its Milwaukee Debut Next Month

“A Gift of The Magi” Makes Its Milwaukee Debut Next Month

This intimate Christmas musical makes its debut at the Milwaukee Chamber Theatre, running through Dec. 6.

Christmas has come early at the Milwaukee Chamber Theatre. A Gift of the Magi welcomes us into the holiday season with the scent of pine (or did I imagine it?) and a pre-show soundtrack of traditional carols, coaxing audiences into the spirit. That nudge toward festive cheer continues as the show’s narrator and two musicians amble onto the stage – an ease to their presence makes you feel at home from the start.

They led the audience in a rousing sing-along of “Joy to the World” before curtain, repeating in chorus: “Let Earth receive her King.” Swiftly, however, we’re tugged from this bountiful moment of Christmas joy to the chill of a drafty tenement building in New York City, 1908. Jim and Della, blissfully married but miserably down on their luck, prepare to face a holiday with nothing but their love to keep them warm.

You may already know them from O. Henry’s 1905 short story The Gift of the Magi. It tells of a young couple wrestling with how to give each other the gift of a fine, sterling Christmas on such little money. A story of selfless love is just what we need in this season of gratitude and giving. 


Gift An Issue For $1 Today!

 

The musical version by James DeVita and Josh Schmidt premiered in 2010 at American Players Theatre. Magi now makes its Milwaukee debut, with some local favorites on stage. Jonathan Gillard Daly, who’s spent 25 years on Milwaukee stages, is the show’s narrator. Newlyweds Jim and Della are Dimonte Henning and Jamie Mercado. Henning is a UW-Milwaukee theater graduate and incoming artistic director for Black Arts MKE; Mercado makes her Chamber Theatre debut.

Daly is his delightful self – the affable, earnest character Milwaukee theatergoers have come to know and love, and pitch-perfect to narrate a Christmas story. He also gets to play a bunch of bit parts – the butcher, the tailor and the owner of a hair-goods shop. All of which earn a smile.

Henning is used to tackling roles rich with angst, so he gets a chance to let go as Jim. He plays the darling husband with boyish optimism and full-on puppy dog eyes for his Della. And Mercado is every inch worthy of that love – standout, sparkling and sweet-voiced. She’s also straight-up funny when she’s haggling to save a penny.

Also on stage are Sky Yela on cello and Susan Nicholson on violin. It’s an engaging artistic choice to position musicians right on stage, though there seemed to be some trouble finding musical balance on opening night. Tone, tempo, the mix of vocals and instruments – the ensemble had to work to find their groove. They course-corrected with the second act opener, complete with wonderful harmonies by Daly, Henning and Mercado.

A favorite scene in Act II is when the musicians enter as street performers to sing “There But For the Grace of God Go I.” Yela leads the song with warmth. It’s a strong, hopeful moment, and one of the most captivating in the show. To me, the ensemble’s delivery of this song sets the emotional bar. Other moments in Magi can feel like a stretch, as the musical turns a short story into a 90-minute show by drawing out certain actions (counting pennies) and adding broader context (a New Yorker’s need for “moxie”) to fill in the gaps. Taken together, the songs are wistfully simple and sweet, but are often melancholic. Perhaps that’s why the uplifting, folksy spirit of “But For the Grace of God” left such an impression.

The look of the show brings the tenement “clothesline canyon” to life. Layered lines of laundry drape across the space for an artful, impactful backdrop. While there’s some furniture on stage, props are intentionally missing – we all must imagine Jim’s newspaper and Della’s groceries. Until the very end, that is, when the Christmas gifts physically appear.

The show then quickly wraps up and could benefit from one last group-sung carol to cement a positive final note. However, Magi will compete with some big holiday fish this season, so leaning far into the intimate nature and scale of the show seems best.

At the start, Yela took a moment to rattle off the names of the talent behind the scenes of this small-scale production: “All these people made this play for you.” That reminder itself is a gift.

Milwaukee Chamber Theatre’s A Gift of the Magi plays the Broadway Theatre Center through Dec. 6.