5 Pi Day Deals That Give You a Great Excuse to Eat Pie

Pi Day is almost upon us and to celebrate, several businesses are offering some special pies or pie deals on Sunday, March 14 (3.14 being the first digits of pi) or the whole weekend.

1. Honeypie

2491 S. SUPERIOR ST. | 414 747-1007

Currently operating its bakeshop out of sister restaurant Palomino, Honeypie is offering pies for pre-order. Pickup and delivery are available through Monday, 3/15. And there are loads of delish-sounding flavors, including three that are a Pi Day exclusive: s’mores, grasshopper and blueberry-peach. Whole pies in those special flavors are 11 inches and run $36 or $41 for a gluten-free crust. Order here

2. Mr. Dye’s Pies

8103 W. TOWER AVE. | 414-759-4992

Get your order in for one of Johnathan Dye’s scrumptious creations. He’s known for his sweet potato, but you should consider branching out to other flavors, including Blueberry Hill, key lime and N’Awlins’ pecan. Half pies $9-$14; whole pies $18-$28. 


Nominations are open for the 2024 Unity Awards! 

Know an individual or group committed to bridging divides in our community? Nominate them for a Unity Award by Oct. 31.

3. The Elegant Farmer

1545 MAIN ST., MUKWONAGO |  262-363-6771

The famed purveyor of apple pie baked in a paper bag is feting pi for three days: March 12-14. And the deal is sweet here. A 5-inch size apple pie is priced at $3.14. It’s said to feed two people, but who are they kidding? For more info, click here

4. LuLu Bar & Café

2265 S. HOWELL AVE. | 414-294-5858

This popular Bay View spot for sandwiches and salads also serves great pie. And on Pi Day, each pie is $1 off. Featured flavors are blueberry, apple, cherry and rhubarb. Call in your order or place it here

5. Hatched

655 BROOKFIELD RD. | 414-465-9176

Baker Allison Cebulla is preparing some doozy choices for Pi Day. One of them is Cranky Al’s Cruller Pie, made with – yes – crullers.  Sounds amazing. Her pre-order deadline has passed but Cebulla plans to have extras of her full menu available on Saturday March 13 (10 a.m.-2 p.m.) and Sunday March 14 (10 a.m.-1 p.m.) at her Brookfield kitchen. These partnering businesses will also carry her creations on Saturday and Sunday: Vennture Brew Co. (6-inch pies, hand pies), Valentine Coffee in Washington Heights and Oak Creek (hand pies), Canary Coffee Bar (hand pies), Hawthorne Coffee Roasters (hand pies), Loup Soups (hand pies) and Kind Oasis (hand pies). Prices vary. Check out all the choices here



Ann Christenson has covered dining for Milwaukee Magazine since 1997. She was raised on a diet of casseroles that started with a pound of ground beef and a can of Campbell's soup. Feel free to share any casserole recipes with her.