I Tried It: Three Milwaukee Nail Salons Get Put to the Test

I Tried It: Three Milwaukee Nail Salons Get Put to the Test

For our Best of Milwaukee feature, one of our editors tested local nail salons to see which one gave her best manicure experience.


READ MORE OF OUR “BEST OF MILWAUKEE 2025” FEATURE HERE.


What makes a good manicure? It’s personal. Some value efficiency; others prefer to be pampered. I tried three local nail salons to compare the experiences, price and quality of the manicure.

Our Readers’ Choice winner, Nail Bar, had the best manicure itself, but it was a quick, nearly spartan process – no chatting, a simple hand massage and sitting by the dryers by yourself afterwards.


It’s time to pick your Milwaukee favorites for the year!

 

Neroli and LUXE, meanwhile, are much more of an experience.

Neroli offers tea while you wait, an aromatherapy hand massage and nail techs interested in talking with you (if you want!), but the manicure was a bit bubbly on one of my thumbs.

LUXE did a sugar scrub and hand massage, but the whole place smelled strongly of chemicals.

The verdict? Neroli had the best experience, if you want to be pampered. Nail Bar had the best manicure itself. 


This story is part of Milwaukee Magazine’s September issue.

Find it on newsstands or buy a copy at milwaukeemag.com/shop.

Be the first to get every new issue. Subscribe.

Brianna Schubert is the former digital editor and continues to write about style, shopping, theater and more for Milwaukee Magazine. When she’s not writing/editing, she’s likely reading, cooking, thrifting or cuddling with her cat.