Mirroring the industry its students
hope to join, Marquette University has carried out a major overhaul in its journalism
Core journalism courses at MU’s Diederich
College of Communication now expose entry-level students to the newest tools
and techniques of professional newsrooms. “If you’re not thinking digital
first, then you’re not equipped to be a success as a journalist in the future,”
says the college’s dean, Lori Bergen.
But some students say the trendy
subjects like video and social media are crowding out basic skills needed by
all journalists. And they’re pushing back.
“I certainly understand what
they’re trying to do,” Andrew Phillips
says of the college’s revisions. Phillips, a journalism and philosophy
double-major, just completed a term as editor in chief of the Marquette Tribune, the twice-weekly student paper.
editorial this past fall, he and other Tribune staffers bemoaned Marquette’s
once focused on the nuances of news writing and beat reporting now teach
students how to write the most gripping cover letter and create the perfectly
polished LinkedIn profile. We were once taught to prioritize context, fairness
and critical thinking. Now, re-tweets, pageviews and self-promotion come before
In an interview, Phillips says the piece was
prompted by a Tribune team’s trip to
the National College Media Convention in Chicago, where seminars and workshops
covered topics like freedom of information requests. They came back dismayed at
how outmatched they felt against peers from campuses across the country.
“They were talking about all these things that
I realize were just basic. But it was totally new to us,” Phillips says. One
group of students discussed the six months they spent on one investigative
reporting project. “We’ve never done one of those.”
The editorial issued “a call for the start of
a conversation” to address “frustrations
among students that cannot be ignored.”
followed involving students, faculty, and administrators over the next
few months. Phillips says students were counseled to be patient and to
understand that “the curriculum is still evolving.”
At one meeting with faculty, he
says, “I said to them … ‘You all have had decades of experience, and this shiny
technology is attractive to you’ Maybe what they’ve done is design a curriculum
that works really well for them because they already have the reporting
Bergen defends Marquette’s new approach. She says the curriculum
remains grounded in fundamental journalistic skills and values: relying on
multiple sources for stories, thinking critically about the issues, treating
people and topics fairly and with appropriate balance, and communicating
“We add to that the aesthetic of
digital media,” says the dean.
about a role reversal. Isn’t it
supposed to be the younger generation championing the flashy new technology,
while the old hands grouse that no one’s teaching the kids the basics anymore?
At the J-school I went to 30 years ago, one of our biggest complaints was
having to write assignments in student classrooms equipped with old manual
office typewriters instead of word-processing computers.)
Marquette once had a two-track curriculum, with print and
broadcast considered virtually separate disciplines. “For a long time, students
had to pick, ‘What part of the news industry do I want to be in?’” Bergen says.
Today, “we teach journalism in one place. The skills that a journalist needs
“There’s writing and reporting in every class,” adds
journalism department chair Karen
Slattery. And by learning across various media, “you begin to learn which
medium works best for which stories.”
Both Bergen and Slattery say journalism students have opportunities
for practical experience early, such as writing for the Neighborhood News Service, which is in
a partnership with the college.
And they promise more to come: Earlier this year the Marquette
announced an $8.3 million grant to set up the
O’Brien Fellowship, enrolling advanced students to undertake in-depth journalism projects. Those students will
be a small, select group – a point of contention for some dissatisfied journalism
majors. But Bergen says plans call for involving many more undergrad classes in
pieces of the fellowship’s projects.
The dean also says she’s heard from
students who are enthusiastic about the new curriculum and have praised it
because “the essential skills they need are really integrated now into the
Phillips isn’t sure how the issue will play out. “I think they understand where we’re coming from,” he
says of faculty and administrators. “What they’ll do with that, I don’t know.”
There’s already been an impact,
says Slattery. Students wanted more direct experience sooner in their classes.
“They didn’t feel like they were getting out early enough to talk to people,”
she says. “Now in the first course, they’re doing that.”
“The faculty continue to take their
concerns very seriously,” she adds. So much so that there are plans to meet
with students more when classes resume in the fall.
“We want to institutionalize these
conversations. I think it’s always important to honor and listen to what people
On the heels of the curriculum controversy, another overhaul has
further rankled student journalists at Marquette. A 5 percent student media
budget cut earlier this year sparked plenty of anger and anguish. And earlier
this month, the Board of Student Media announced a restructuring
program that, like the revised curriculum, is rooted in a “digital first”
The plan joins the university’s
four student media outlets – The Tribune,
the magazine The Marquette Journal,
and student radio and television stations –
together in a single “NewsCenter” website staffed by a pool of reporters
and editors. More budget cuts are expected.
The media conflict and the
curriculum complaints aren’t directly connected – student media are extracurricular
activities run separately from the journalism academic program. But they can’t
help but overlap, especially because of similarities between them.
An end-of-semester Tribune editorial acknowledged the
rationale for the convergence proposal – then decried
the specifics as “a hastily produced plan that
blatantly ignores student input and ‘evolved’ simply for the sake of evolving,
a plan that puts the quality of student media at risk.”
recent study from the consulting firm McKinsey & Co. might give the Tribune’s print loyalists a fresh talking
about the growing dominance of digital media over traditional forms might be premature.
At the very least, the picture McKinsey paints is a bit more complicated.
When the time people actually
engage with particular platforms is taken into account, the legacy media still
win. And they do so in
a big way.
Another buyout: The
Journal Sentinel has instituted yet
another buyout program, I’ve learned. On the plus side, the thinking appears to
be that the newsroom isn’t the focus, although some reporters may weigh the
deal – especially since the severance terms (two weeks’ pay for every year of service)
actually exceed those called for in the newest newsroom union contract.
Comment below, or write Pressroom at email@example.com.