That’s a menu featuring starters like a charcuterie and cheese board ($6-$25), sides such as roasted meatballs with grits and Pleasant Ridge Reserve cheese ($12), mains including grilled whitefish with tomato butter and mustard ($17) and platters (for 2-4 diners) of grilled rib-eye steak with roasted potatoes and salsa verde ($36). Birch butchers also break down steers to produce roasts, chops and sausage, selling them in the shop, along with cheeses from Wisconsin and beyond, espresso drinks and other odds and ends.
From my seat at one of the banquettes, I take in the long counter facing the kitchen. Breads are stacked, fresh from the morning bake. Wood-roasted bagels studded with seeds or topped with melted cheese are piled on a platter on the butcher shop side, on top of the glass charcuterie case – a mix of the shop’s house-cured wares and Madison’s Underground Meats. Runners ferry plates of barbecued parsnips with chile and yogurt and grilled rib-eye with roasted potatoes to diners in this ground-level space seating 132 inside (with plans for an outdoor patio in summer).
“Contemporary Midwestern” is the culinary theme of the menu. At this writing, a month or so in, some hiccups showed, but not too many. The sweet potato gnocchi with sunchokes and fresh savory is one ($13). I like the strong, thyme-like flavor of the herb and the nutty, sweet sunchoke, roasted until tender. But I push the mushy gnocchi aside.
I also love the idea of a bread board. The sliced, crusty rye yeast breads are a little dried out, but the soft and light whipped butter, topped with coarse sea salt, is a treat ($3).
The sunflower seed risotto with meaty king trumpet mushrooms ($14) is creamy and tender. It could ride shotgun with any of the meats/fish or stand on its own, tempering the bitter grilled rapini topped with raisins and slightly pungent Evalon cheese ($10) and providing texture alongside chewy, deliciously charred BBQ parsnips ($10). The risotto brings a nutty edge to the rich, pink fillet of butter-poached steelhead trout ($20). The roasted meatballs are a just-fine wintery plate, three coarse-ground pork-beef balls in fine-textured grits enhanced by Pleasant Ridge Reserve cheese ($12).
The statement maker of the menu is the whole roasted chicken, hot, charred and very flavorful in its cooking vessel (a clay pot) – with roasty BBQ carrots, parsnips and an herby carrot-top gremolata ($34).
It’s the perfect hearth dish and a great example of Birch + Butcher’s reason for being. More of that sharp edge and the place will hit its stride. ◆
Birch + Butcher
459 E. Pleasant St., 414-323-7372
Hours: Mon-Thurs 5-10 p.m.; Fri-Sat 5-11 p.m. (Butcher shop/cafe opens at 7:30 a.m. daily)
Prices: Main dishes $15-$32; platters $26-$36
Service: Staff seems invested, knowledgeable