For over four decades, Pop’s Custard has served frozen treats, burgers and more in Menomonee Falls (N87 W16459 Appleton Ave.). On Monday, the restaurant announced on Facebook that it would be closing its doors. It will remain open until Aug. 31.
“Navigating the last few years has been an incredible challenge,” the announcement read. “The long road to recovery post-COVID, coupled with increases in food and labor costs, has created an obstacle we can no longer overcome. We’ve poured our hearts into keeping Pop’s the small-town custard shop that you loved from your childhood. We are incredibly proud and honored to have been a part of your memories.
Tell us who you’d pick to be a Betty this year!
The restaurant is now for sale. “We are hopeful that someone will continue to serve up delicious food to our amazing community and be able to dedicate the time and effort that it deserves,” said the announcement.
The social media post announcing the closure has since received hundreds of comments and shares. Here are just a few:
“So many memories at Pop’s. From eating my first cone, to my first job in high school, to Mrs. Whittman sticking free quarts in my bag when she saw me pick up a to go order. Thanks to the current owner for keeping it going this long, and I hope someone continues the tradition.”
“My daughter just said there should be a go fund me to keep you open! Thanks for the best burger and fries since my childhood!”
“You have the best custard around. And your ham and cheese melt is sooooo good! Hope someone buys it and keeps it going…thank you for all of the deliciousness over the years!”
