How to Curate Your Home Bar | Milwaukee Magazine

How to Curate Your Home Bar

A local bartender shares her must-haves.


THIS STORY IS PART OF MILWAUKEE MAGAZINE’S FOOD LOVERS GUIDE. CLICK HERE TO READ MORE. 


Annabella Shore’s love of cooking shows in her cocktails. The lead bartender at Birch (459 E. Pleasant St.) was raised in a family with Puerto Rican and Dominican ancestry. “I try to [incorporate] things that I was raised eating and drinking,” she says, as well as unexpected ingredients like ube (purple yam) and pandan (a Southeast Asian herb). You don’t need to go overboard in your home bar. But you do need some basics. Here are her staples: 

Shaker Tins

Every home bar needs at least one and preferably two shakers. This type, a cobbler shaker, works fine, but Shore recommends two-piece Boston shakers (the ones that look like an inverted cup fitted into a cup).

Mixing Glass

Used for a stirred, not shaken, cocktail. The stainless steel ones will keep a drink really cold, but Shore prefers glass, with a heavy base and narrow spout, from the brand Cocktail Kingdom. 


If someone has inspired you through their service, leadership or dedication, the Unity Awards are your opportunity to recognize them!

 

Swiveled Bar Spoon 

You want a long one that reaches the bottom of the mixing glass, and the swivel design serves an important purpose: If you pour a carbonated beverage slowly down the spoon’s swiveled stem, the soda will not fizz over. Test it out for yourself!    

Shot Glass

An aesthetic must. “Spend a little money on a really cute [one].”  

Jigger

This dual-sided measuring cup helps ensure consistent cocktails. “They have lines in them to let you know exactly how much you’re pouring and what you need.” 

Drinking Glasses

Go thrifting and buy what strikes your fancy. “You’re always gonna find the coolest stuff, the very unique stuff.” For glassware in general, Shore sticks to this: juice glasses (for wine, any type), 8- to 10-ounce rocks glasses, and a bell-shaped Glencairn glass for sipping scotch and mezcal.


Shore’s Liquor Case Favorites

VODKA

Absolut Elyx – “The flavor is rich and beautiful … the only vodka I can drink.” 

RYE

Rittenhouse – “The only [whiskey] I put in my Manhattans.” 

BOURBON

Old Grand Dad – “Consistent flavor. The Old Grand Dad I had in 2001 tastes exactly the same as the one I have right now.” 

GIN

Citadelle – “Absolutely stunning. I don’t have to put anything in it. I can just sip it.” 

BITTERS

Angostura, Peychaud’s and an orange bitters like Regan’s – for Manhattans and old fashioneds. 

VERMOUTH

Carpano Antica (sweet) and Dolin (dry) 

WILD CARDS

Pierre Ferrand Dry Curaçao, for margaritas 

Fernet-Branca, served neat or in cocktails


This story is part of Milwaukee Magazine’s December issue.

Find it on newsstands or buy a copy at milwaukeemag.com/shop.

Be the first to get every new issue. Subscribe.

Ann Christenson has covered dining for Milwaukee Magazine since 1997. She was raised on a diet of casseroles that started with a pound of ground beef and a can of Campbell's soup. Feel free to share any casserole recipes with her.