It really was over for him.
You might have heard in the past couple weeks that Jake Bauers was done with baseball. Or, perhaps more pointedly, baseball was done with him.
That’s what happens when you swing and miss too often for too long. Five organizations – Tampa, Cleveland, Seattle, Cincinnati and the Yankees – had tried their luck without sustained success, and after a sixth one stepped up to the plate and largely whiffed, that looked to be it.
Yes, even when the Brewers traded for Bauers after the 2023 season, and even after they tried working their reclamation magic on him, things weren’t clicking. He hit .199 in 2024, and even that modest output came as a heavily platooned player, and they let him become a free agent in the offseason.
Celebrate this year’s winners of the Betty Awards!
So yes, he was ready to call it quits. And yes, he came back, on a pride-swallowing minor-league deal with the Brewers as a 29-year-old, albeit one with a big-league spring training invite.
And yes, because of the health insurance.
That 2025 season showed enough promise and progress that the Brewers gave him a second one-year deal for 2026, a full big-league contract that doubled his salary to $2.7 million. He delivered a remarkable return on that investment. Thrust into full-time action after an early-season injury to first baseman Andrew Vaughn, Bauers hit .266 with 26 homers and 86 RBIs to far surpass his career highs.
“Jake got an opportunity; that’s what he got,” Brewers’ manager Pat Murphy said during the team’s sweep of the Los Angeles Dodgers. “He got an opportunity to contribute, and he kind of found his offensive approach.”
That he almost quit, only to come back, isn’t super rare among ballplayers. That he almost quit and came back to achieve so much in the space of two years is a different kettle of fish.
“It’s a growth in the game,” Murphy said. “He’s continued to grow.”
Because Bauers has hit the comeback trifecta. He not only found his biggest personal success, but did so on the game’s biggest stage while carrying his franchise through some of its most important moments. In fact, as impressive and complete as Milwaukee’s sweep of the Dodgers was, you can make an argument that none of it happens without Bauers.
His clutch 12-pitch walk in Game 2 against star starter Yoshinobu Yamamoto turned the game, and likely the series, on its head. It piled pressure and fatigue on Yamamoto while setting the stage for Christian Yelich’s go-ahead single that knocked the Dodgers ace from the game. It was the difference between going to Los Angeles tied at 1 game piece and taking a commanding 2-0 lead to the coast.
Then, once on that coast, with people still marveling at how Bauers delivered his epic at-bat, he went out and improved on it in Game 3. Against a dominant Blake Snell, he delivered a second epic. This time, only 11 pitches. This time, only ending it with a go-ahead two-run homer. Complete with an epic bat flip.
After the Brewers completed their revenge sweep over the Dodgers in Game 4 – with the help of three more Bauers RBIs – he was rewarded for the heroics with more attention than he’s ever known in his career.
He was named the National League Championship Series MVP. Networks devoted entire segments to breaking down his patience, his swing changes and dissecting those two epic at-bats with the surgical precision usually reserved for true crime re-enactments. Beyond that, his inspiring personal story became part and parcel of his folklore, especially the part about going back to baseball mainly to secure health insurance for his then-pregnant wife, Lauren.
And lest you think he was only a hot story for sports audiences, think again. Because places like Good Morning America sent camera crews to chronicle his story and spread it far beyond the baseball faithful.
Through it all, he’s displayed the newfound peace that’s carried him to new heights.
“I think what changed for me this year,” Bauers said during the Dodgers series, “was I stopped caring about results. I started caring about competing. I started caring about being in the moment and getting out of my own way.”
It’s also translated into a quiet leadership role, one reflective of the team-wide confidence the Brewers displayed in beating the Dodgers. In the wake of his MVP award, while the Brewers celebrated at Dodger Stadium, he put his and the team’s transformation into perspective.
“I can’t speak on anybody else, but for me, watching the way they carried themselves on the field after sweeping us last year was a little bit eye-opening. Those guys swept us, they sent us home, and you would have thought it was a handshake line at a spring training game,” Bauers said. “That’s something that I carried with me. That’s something that I remembered.
Now, the Brewers have only a World Series left to play, against the Tampa Bay Rays, who gave him his major league debut. When it’s done, Bauers will be a free agent again after the 2026 season, but two things are sure.
He’ll have far bigger offers than a minor league deal, be they with the Brewers or other organizations, and he won’t come back just for health insurance.
