Where to Get Christmas Cookies in Milwaukee This Year

Here are a few places around Milwaukee where you can find delicious seasonal bakery items.

RELATED: HOLIDAY COOKIE RECIPES

1. Aggie’s Bakery

7328 W. GREENFIELD AVE., WEST ALLIS

Aggie’s Bakery uses old fashioned recipes to bake festive cookies and treats for any occasion! Enjoy their White Chocolate Christmas Cookie, White Chocolate Christmas Tree Cookie, assorted sugar cookies or more this holiday season. Assorted flavors of petite cookies are available in store daily, or order online for special orders and deliveries.

2. National Bakery & Deli

LOCATIONS IN MILWAUKEE, BROOKFIELD AND GREENDALE

Keeping up with the change of seasons, National Deli & Bakery constantly changes their menu to offer a selection of seasonal items. From hand-decorated cookies to old-fashioned pies, this place has it all! For this year’s Christmas cookie selection, National Deli & Bakery has decorated butter tea cookies, Pecan Fingers Christmas cookies, Gingerbread men and assorted sugar cutout cookies. They also offer a Heart Shaped Santa Cake and Holiday Decorated Cake, as well as a variety of other unique desserts including Pfefferneusse, Rum Balls and Taffy Apple.

 

 

3. Black Twig Bakery

1455 UNDERWOOD AVE., WAUWATOSA

Black Twig Bakery has a special menu for the month of December with a list of tasty cupcakes, cookies and macarons to try. Enjoy a peppermint, brown butter or oatmeal cookie sandwiches. Or, get a taste of their cranberry orange or salted caramel gingerbread cupcakes. You can also choose from an assortment of macaron flavors, including peppermint bark, eggnog, hot chocolate, sugar cookie dough or gingerbread.

4. Cookies From Scratch

427 YORKSHIRE DR., COLGATE

Cookies From Scratch is known for their party-sized cookie assortments. This year, enjoy their Frosted Double Stuff Christmas Stars, Snowflake Christmas Buttercreams or Cookies for Santa packages. Visit their website to order online and view all their options!

5. Scordato Bakery

5011 W. HOWARD AVE. 

This bakery is offering a 1 pound Holiday Cookie Tray with an assortment of some of their most popular holiday cookies for $13.49. You can also order individual cookies, like their chocolate bon bon cookie, vanilla butter star cookie and more.

6. Cookies By Design

17000 W. BLUEMOUND RD., BROOKFIELD 

Cookies By Design has creative cookie gift baskets to share with loved ones during the holiday season. Each of their Christmas decorated cookies are handcrafted and arranged with care. Some of their newest gift baskets include Home for the Holidays and Merry Christmask, with unique decorated cookies of Santa, snowmen and reindeer wearing face masks.

Comments

comments

Skyler Chun is an editorial intern at Milwaukee Magazine. She is currently a sophomore at Marquette University studying Journalism and Digital Media.