Your Local Valentine’s Day Gift Guide (2025)
Gift box with a bow and a bouquet of red tulips, top view, background

Your Local Valentine’s Day Gift Guide

Dining, drinks, sweets and more ideas to impress your special someone.

Valentine’s Day can be overwhelming – gifts to get, dates to plan, etc. Consider this local guide inspiration, whether you’re preparing for a night on the town or just trying to find the perfect gift. 

Ursa Herbal Tea and Ceramic Mugs

Surprise your valentine with a comforting herbal tea in a beautifully handcrafted ceramic mug. Ursa offers several styles so you can choose the mug that matches your loved one’s taste. 

Freese’s Chocolate Heart Boxes

Nothing says Valentine’s like a heart-shaped box of chocolates. It’s a classic for a reason. Freese’s offers this timeless gift with an assorted collection of their rich chocolates in quarter-pound, half-pound and one-pound sizes. 


SPONSORED SPOTLIGHT

Casablanca: Film with Orchestra, Feb. 14-16

“Of all the gin joints, in all the towns, in all the world, she walks into mine.” Walk into Allen-Bradley Hall Valentine’s weekend and experience one of classic Hollywood’s most romantic tales on the big screen with live orchestral accompaniment. Cozy up with a loved one as you savor the story of Rick and Ilsa’s romance, the beautiful visuals, and the Milwaukee Symphony Orchestra performing Max Steiner’s Oscar-winning score live in sync with the iconic film. Buy tickets today at mso.org or 414-291-7605.


Broadway Paper Valentine’s Cards

Step up your Valentine’s card game with a selection from this Third Ward stationary store. Broadway Paper’s collection of Valentine’s Day cards runs the gamut from romantic to silly fun.

Cupid’s Stoplight: An Anti-Valentine’s Day Soiree

Looking for an unconventional Valentine’s Day celebration? Uptown Society is hosting this event for everyone “single, taken or somewhere in between” at Northern Lights Event Venue on Feb. 14. When you arrive, you can choose a wristband color – red means taken, green means single and looking, and yellow means open to connecting but not actively seeking someone. (You can skip the wristband, too, if you’d prefer.) Tickets come with a complimentary beer or wine and charcuterie. 

414loral’s Valentine’s Day Bouquets

From eye-catching begonias to elaborate seasonal bouquets, 414loral offers unique arrangements of all kinds. The shop provides local delivery or pick-up options in time for the holiday with pre-orders ending Feb. 8.


SPONSORED SPOTLIGHT

All-In For Love at Potawatomi Casino Hotel

Dine and relax in luxury at Potawatomi Casino Hotel. Plan an overnight extravagance right in Downtown Milwaukee. Dine at the award-winning Dream Dance Steakhouse or one of the 10 other dining options, then stay the night in a luxurious hotel room, just steps from limitless excitement. What’s not to love?


Chocolate & Wine Tasting

Join The Pfister Hotel’s executive pastry chef Travis Martinez in a guided tasting of eight decadent Valrhona chocolates and four paired wines on Saturday, Feb. 8, at 7 p.m. The experience will take guests on a journey through the rich history of chocolate.

Ormson Supply Valentine’s Engravings

Have your names engraved in this custom heart design from Ormson Supply. While you’re there, consider checking out the store’s lineup of vintage clothing and home goods – you might just find another great gift. 

Wisconsin’s Finest Box from Burke Candy

Give in to your Valentine’s sweet tooth with Burke’s top-selling candies – English toffee and sea salt caramels, made with locally-sourced Wisconsin AA butter.  

Valentine’s in Shanghai

Enter a hidden world of craft cocktails and Cream City brick at Black Cat Alley’s Shanghai Speakeasy. Book a Valentine’s in Shanghai night, and you’ll get a signature cocktail, glass of champagne and truffles from Indulgence Chocolatiers. 

Make and Take Your Own Aphrodisiac Tea

Spice up Valentine’s Day by making a unique tea blend at Tippecanoe Herbs on Feb. 14. Staff will help you and your loved one create the ideal concoction. Reserve a spot at the workshop online

A Weekend at The Trade

The Trade, Milwaukee’s newest Deer District hotel, is offering a Feb. 14-15 “Endless Amore” package that includes dinner for two at II Cervo, two tickets for a Flamenco show at Solomon’s, and complimentary valet parking.

Yolo Home Co. Silhouette Art Workshop

Learn how to make an eye-catching custom silhouette portrait with Jenni Yolo of Yolo Home Co. She’s hosting this workshop on Feb. 8. Just provide a side profile picture of yourself, your partner, or even a pet beforehand and she’ll provide the necessary materials to create the portrait. 

Neroli Salon & Spa Gift Card

Give someone special a serene salon or spa experience at Neroli, whether it’s a relaxing massage, facial, nails or other treatment.

Custom Orange and Blue Co. Gift Set

Surprise your valentine with a curated gift set from Orange and Blue Co. home goods. Choose a dollar amount for the set (anywhere from $35-$500), then tell the folks at Orange and Blue a little about your loved one and they’ll do the shopping for you, crafting a gift set customized to their preferences. 

Edie’s Hearts & Clovers Collection 

This charming collection from Edie Boutique offers Valentine-themed home decor, stationery, candles and even fuzzy sweaters and cardigans for your partner.  

A Glassnote Candle Bar Experience

Bring your Valentine to Glassnote Candle Bar to create something as lovely as they are. Learn to make candles, while enjoying craft cocktails and mocktails. Glassnote’s packages start at $45 for one candle and $85 for two.