Milwaukee dining obscura

6 Under-the-Radar Restaurants to Try in Milwaukee

Follow these paths to uncover a sleeper-status establishment well worth the journey to find.

Milwaukee dining obscura
Illustrations by Brock Kaplan

Sherman Perk

This community-minded cafe (4924 W. Roosevelt Dr.), a former fi lling station, is warm and welcoming and a knockout example of Streamline Moderne architecture.

Amaranth Bakery and Cafe

They had us at rugelach. And at kouign-amann (a flaky, incredibly rich French pastry). This charming little bakery and cafe (3329 W. Lisbon Ave.) has remained under the radar since it opened in 2006.

Pacific Produce

A visit to this Asian market (5455 S. 27th St.) is never just a visit. It’s an adventure filled with duck heads, shelves of kimchi, squid jerky, jackfruit, Korean rice cakes and prepared foods, too.

Valley Inn

This tavern (4000 W. Clybourn St.) in the quaint residential area of Piggsville (west end of the Menomonee River Valley) is beloved by its neighbors, who’d probably like to keep the bomber sandwiches, pizzas and nightly specials all to themselves.

4th Base

Sports memorabilia is festooned everywhere at this glorified bar (5117 W. National Ave.), where the menu offers vague “suggestions” (think seabass and bacon-wrapped scallops), but no prices. The final tally is a mystery until the bill arrives.

Conway’s Smokin’ Bar and Grill

How this BBQ joint (2127 W. Wells St.) with smoky, charred chicken wings, beef brisket and meatloaf keeps a profile so low, we don’t know, but we’re singing its praises in baritone.

Map of all 31 Hidden Milwaukee Spots

Hidden Milwaukee‘ appears in the May 2017 issue of Milwaukee Magazine.

Find it on newsstands beginning May 1, or buy a copy at

Be the first to get every new issue. Subscribe.