Dining          Events          A&E          Style          The Daily Mil          Blogs          Photos          Guides          Magazine
Best Schools
Wisconsin's open-enrollment law allows students to attend any public school in the state. We rank 50+ local choices.

 

For Mequon-Thiensville's Julie King, teaching reading is a royal passion.

Story by Matt Hrodey
Photos by Adam Ryan Morris
 
Julie King had a student who was afraid of her own ideas. The girl was “very shy, someone who had struggled in school up to that point,” says the reading specialist at Steffen Middle School in the Mequon-Thiensville School District. Like other students, the sixth-grader had been sent to King for extra help.

Something about writing her ideas down and leaving them vulnerable to judgment unsettled the student, and she was now reluctantly creating an outline for what would later become an essay.

“Then we took that permanence away,” says King, who had the student write her ideas on sticky notes and then place them on the form she was using to write the outline. One by one, the girl organized the little pieces of paper.

“We talked about what didn’t fit,” says the specialist, who asked the student, “Does that fit in that paragraph? No? Let’s take it out.”

Discarded ideas accumulated on the table. Then the student noticed where they could fit, and the outline grew. The exercise became a breakthrough for the young writer.

In
Milwaukee Magazine’s new study of Best Schools, King’s district ranked as the Best Overall K-12 District, a category that took into account scores on the Wisconsin Knowledge and Concepts Examination (WKCE) standardized test that’s administered to elementary, middle and high school students. It also factored in ACT and Advanced Placement test results, indicators of college readiness.

Of the 33 Milwaukee-area K-12 districts studied, several others boasted similarly high scores, including Whitefish Bay, our No. 1 Top Scorer in the high school category, as well as Elmbrook, Germantown, Cedarburg and Greendale.

Asked why their districts excel, administrators tout various programs and initiatives, each slightly different in approach.

At Mequon-Thiensville, Superintendent Demond Means points to the district’s fixation on developing literacy – the skills of reading, writing, speaking and listening – in all content areas, even math.

“It’s the engine that drives our curriculum,” he says. “We ask kids to express themselves in writing in every subject.”

For some five years, the high-scoring district has placed reading specialists – specially certified teachers armed with advanced skills in literacy intervention – at each of its three elementary and two middle schools.

“We follow a systematic approach,” says Heidi Pergande, the Donges Bay Elementary specialist. “It takes about 10 years to become what we consider a proficient reader.” The process typically runs from ages 5 to 15.

“We like to say we are preventing reading deficiencies instead of alleviating them,” she says.

Mequon-Thiensville, like some other districts in Wisconsin, is adding more nonfiction books and articles to its curriculum, partly to get more boys engrossed in reading. Anna Young, the Lake Shore Middle School specialist, says boys are often more interested in real-life subject matter.

Recently, while reading such a book with a small group of boys, she noticed something unusual out of the corner of her eye. “I could see on my sides,” she says, “that these young men were peeling back the pages and looking ahead.”

That’s the X-factor: student interest. “It’s magic,” she says. “It’s this magic thing.”

It’s present at younger ages, too, according to Pergande. “Boys rush into the library to the snakes and the lizards and the motorcycles.”

But districts are also teaching more nonfiction because it improves reading comprehension, she says. “Nonfiction demands more of the reader, and you have to be more sophisticated in your approach to it.”

Knowing when to leave kids alone is also an important part of a reading specialist’s job, they say. Tara Webster, the Oriole Lane Elementary specialist, says it took until her second year of teaching (she started out teaching second grade) to “learn to sit back and let the kids read.”

The results could be astonishing. Sometimes, she says, “You could hear a pin drop.”




6 Comments
You must login to post a comment. Login or Register

Greg M Posted: 5/10/2012 12:37:27 PM
 1   1    

So glad to see that your flawed methodology left out the two top performing high schools in the state. Was it because that under your statistical model it would have left MPS and Racine ahead of your other schools in the over-acheiving catagory? Or is this because your target audience, particularly for the consumption of this type of "study" is a suburban parent. Not someone who actually lives inside the city limits. Either way, this isn't a study of Milwaukee area schools when you leave out more school then you include.
John Hartland Posted: 3/28/2012 12:13:50 PM
 1   2    

Was it noted in the article that those 3 were left out?
John Hartland Posted: 3/28/2012 10:37:07 AM
 6   2    

You failed to mention Arrowhead. I researched the ACT, AP, and other criteria you used, and found it should have been in the top few. No where was it to be found. Yet the top four K-8 schools listed in your own article all feed into Arrowhead. If you just read your story, all those kids from those top four k-8 districts go from top ranking to not making the top 30. Did those kids all of a sudden become severe under performers? That is the conclusion you would make from YOUR story. Your conclusions are VERY WRONG and MISLEADING. I would like to see a clarification on why Arrowhead is not listed. Why did you list the feeder schools to Arrowhead, but not Arrowhead?
Matt Hrodey Posted: 3/28/2012 11:41:05 AM
 1   2    

There were a total of three union high school districts left out -- Nicolet, Arrowhead, and Union Grove -- and not included in the 54 K-8 and K-12 districts we ranked using the methodologies described in the story. We ranked Arrowhead's feeder districts because they are K-8 districts. We didn't rank Arrowhead because it's not a K-12 district.
Matt Hrodey Posted: 3/28/2012 9:26:49 AM
 3   6    

We didn’t include union high school districts, those that include only high school grades and not a full K-12 system. This left out Nicolet. All the other districts ranked were full K-12 or K-8 districts. Union high school districts present a couple wrinkles with respect to data. For one, students are only in these districts a little more than a year when they take the WKCE in 10th grade, and WKCE results were a key factor in all of our rankings.
Patricia Posted: 3/27/2012 5:44:07 PM
 5   8    

81.4 % of Nicolet seniors in 2010 took the ACT with an average composite score of 24.4. 21.5% of 9-12th graders took at least one AP exam, and 72.5% of attempts resulted in a passing score of 3 or better. AP exams were taken in 25 areas. I find it inexcusable that you did not even mention this outstanding high school in this article. Whatever your criteria were, they were insufficient for providing your readership with unbiased reporting if you managed to entirely overlook Nicolet. I live in Elmbrook's school district, and I never attended any schools other than graduate school in this state, but I am apparently either better informed or less biased than your reporter and editorial staff.
MOST Viewed
Reasons to Love Milwaukee
POSTED 9/25/2014

A House Divided
POSTED 7/7/2014

The Aftermath
POSTED 7/28/2014

Crack of Dawn
POSTED 7/28/2014

High Impact
POSTED 10/7/2014

MOST Commented
The Aftermath
POSTED 7/28/2014

No Place Like Home
POSTED 8/25/2014

Depth Of Field
POSTED 7/8/2014

A House Divided
POSTED 7/7/2014

On Common Grounds
POSTED 6/30/2014